Nothing upsets a community faster than suspecting a giveaway was rigged. Fair does not just mean “random”. Fair means: everyone understands beforehand how the draw works, the odds make sense, and nobody wins with a trick the others do not have.
Which randomness is good enough
Many programming languages have two kinds of randomness: a fast one that is fine for games and animations, and a cryptographically secure one whose next number cannot be predicted even with a lot of effort. For a giveaway with a real prize, only the second one will do. In PHP that is random_int, for example, which we use for our draws.
As a streamer you usually cannot see your tool’s code. Ask the provider what the draw uses. A clear answer is a good sign; dodging the question is not.
Rolling dice, a prize wheel on stream or a randomiser website are perfectly fine for small giveaways, as long as everyone is watching. What matters is that the randomness is not in your hands.
Entries: how the odds are split
In a giveaway with entries the maths is simple: your chance is the number of your entries divided by all entries in the pot. More entries mean better odds, not a guaranteed win.
| Viewer | Entries | Chance |
|---|---|---|
| A | 100 | 50 % |
| B | 50 | 25 % |
| C | 1 | 0.5 % |
| 49 more | 1 each | 0.5 % each |
The example shows the problem: without a limit, a single heavy viewer buys half the pot. Two adjustments help:
- A cap per person. With us it is configurable, 100 entries by default. For small channels, less is often fairer.
- One entry for everyone. For quick giveaways in between: everyone gets exactly one entry, the same chance for all.
If you draw several winners, each winner drops out for the remaining places of the same draw. Otherwise one person with many entries can win two prizes at once.
Alt accounts and bot accounts
The biggest threat to a fair giveaway are accounts that only exist to take part. There is no fully automatic, reliable detection. What helps:
- Count by Twitch ID, not by name. Names can be changed. When entries are counted by ID, renaming does not get anyone a second entry.
- Earn entries rather than hand them out. If entries come from watch time or points, a fresh throwaway account is hardly worth it.
- Follower requirement with a minimum duration. Twitch provides the time of every follow. A tool can use it to require that someone has followed for a few days. A follower requirement without a minimum barely stops throwaway accounts, because following costs nothing.
- Block list. Known bot accounts that only lurk to collect watch time belong on a list that does not enter the draw. Review it now and then so no real viewer ends up on it by mistake.
- Set the rule beforehand. State in the official rules that alt accounts are excluded and what happens then.
Response deadline and redraw
A winner who has left the stream blocks the prize. That is why every draw needs a response deadline: the winner confirms in chat, for example with !claim, that they are there.
- Short for live giveaways. With us it is 90 seconds by default. Anyone watching can easily make that.
- Longer for big prizes. For a prize raffled over several days, rather 24 to 48 hours with a message to the winner.
- Redraw without previous winners. If nobody responds, draw again. Anyone already drawn no longer takes part.
- Slow down false claims. Writing
!claimwithout having won is disruptive. Our system blocks such accounts from the community pot for a while.
Stay transparent
If someone later asks whether everything was above board, only an answer you can back up helps. For every draw, note:
- Time of the draw and who ran it.
- Total number of entries and how many the winner had.
- Who was drawn, who responded and who moved up in a redraw.
- Who was excluded before the draw, such as moderators or accounts on the block list.
Draw live and let chat watch. Legal questions such as official rules and data protection are covered in the guide Giveaways on Twitch. How the StreamWizard giveaway system handles entries, response deadlines and redraws is described on its page.
Checklist
- Is the draw made with cryptographically secure randomness or visibly live?
- Cap on entries per person set?
- Several winners: do winners drop out for the remaining places?
- Entries counted by Twitch ID, alt accounts excluded in the rules?
- Response deadline suited to the prize, and redraws without previous winners?
- Time, entries and winners written down?